Indianapolis
Investment Analysis

Indianapolis, IN
Investor Report

Comprehensive real estate investment analysis with cap rates, rental yields, and risk assessment.

Share:
47
Investment Score
Strong Buy
Cap Rate (Est.)
3.3%
Gross Yield
5.5%
P/R Ratio
13.8x
YoY Growth
+1.0%
Median Home Price
$250,000
Average Rent (1BR)
$1,145/mo
Median Income
$66,629
Population
874,182

Investment Breakdown

59
Value Score
60
Growth Score
0
Safety Score
55
Afford Score

Indianapolis has a price-to-rent ratio of 13.8x, which indicates buying is significantly better than renting.

The estimated cap rate of 3.3% is below average, typical of appreciation-focused markets.

Year-over-year price growth of +1.0% indicates stable market conditions.

Rental Cash Flow Analysis

Monthly Income

Gross Rent $1,145
Annual Gross $13,740

Est. Monthly Expenses

Property Tax (~1.5%) -$313
Insurance (~0.5%) -$104
Maintenance (~1%) -$208
Est. Net Cash Flow $520/mo

Price Forecast 2026–2028

🔮 Indianapolis Price Forecast 20262028

Based on 5-year Zillow ZHVI trend analysis · Statistical projection
📈 Upward Trend
PROJECTEDNOW$223K2027$242K 8.4%2028$252K 12.7%20232024Now
$264K$201K
Current
$250K
2026
Projected
$242K
8.4% by 2027
Projected
$252K
12.7% by 2028
5yr CAGR:+6.1%
Confidence:Moderate
R²:0.79

Looking at the Indianapolis housing market forecast for 2026-2028, the city appears well-positioned for steady, sustainable growth rather than explosive gains. The current median home price of $223,230 remains significantly below national averages, bolstered by a price-to-rent ratio of 14.9x—well under the 18x national benchmark—making it an attractive market for both owner-occupants and long-term investors. While the modest 0.2% year-over-year price change suggests near-term cooling, the 36.9% five-year appreciation demonstrates resilient underlying demand. This balance is crucial for those asking: will Indianapolis home prices drop? The data points to stabilization rather than decline, supported by strong affordability and a risk grade of A.

The local economic backdrop continues to drive housing demand in the Indianapolis real estate market Indianapolis 2027 outlook. Major employers in healthcare, logistics, and technology—anchored by institutions like Eli Lilly and Salesforce—provide stable job growth that fuels household formation. With days on market averaging 39 and a market temperature of 63/100, properties are moving at a healthy pace without the frenzied competition seen in hotter markets. The city’s affordability advantage compared to coastal metros should continue attracting both domestic migrants and young professionals, supporting price stability even as broader economic conditions fluctuate.

For the 2026-2028 period, expect moderate appreciation in the 3-5% range annually, outpacing inflation but remaining grounded in fundamentals. The five-year CAGR of 6.4% provides a realistic baseline, though future growth will likely moderate given the current price level and broader economic uncertainties. Investors should note the “BUY” verdict stems from strong rental demand and favorable cash flow potential, with median rent at $1,145/month supporting positive returns. While no market is immune to macroeconomic shocks, Indianapolis offers a compelling blend of stability, affordability, and growth potential for those with a medium-to-long-term horizon.

Projected Cap Rate (2027)
3.5%
5yr CAGR
+6.1%

Job Market

Unemployment 3.4%
National avg: 3.7%
Job Growth (YoY) +1.5%

Healthcare

70
Score
Good

Risk Factors

High Crime Area

Market Activity

Source: Redfin · 2026-01-31
Sale-to-List 96.7%
Months Supply 4.0
Price Drops 35%
Gone in 2 Wks 25%

Market Position

Affordability Below Avg
Safety Higher Risk

ROI Projector Estimate your total return

Adjust the sliders to model different investment scenarios for Indianapolis.

Total ROI
-63%
on $50,000 invested
Annual ROI
-18.2%
compounded
Total Return
-$31,729
appreciation + cashflow
Mo. Cash Flow
-$841
year 1 estimate
Equity Growth Over 5 Years
Y155kY259kY364kY469kY574k
Appreciation
$12,622
Cash Flow
-$44,352
Final Equity
$74,343

* Estimates based on 1.0% annual appreciation, 3% rent growth, 5% vacancy. Does not include closing costs, tax benefits, or capital gains tax. For illustrative purposes only.

Rental Investment Calculator Estimate your monthly cashflow

Rental Income Estimator

Pre-filled for Indianapolis

Property

Purchase Price$250,000
Monthly Rent$1,145
Down Payment20%

Financing

Interest Rate6.5%

Expenses

Property Tax1.2%
Insurance (Annual)$1,500
Maintenance Reserve1%
Vacancy Rate5%
Property Management0%
HOA (Monthly)$0
-$760
Monthly Cash Flow
-$9,117/ year
-18.2%
Cash-on-Cash
2.4%
Cap Rate

Monthly Breakdown

+ Rental Income$1,145
− Mortgage (P&I)$1,264
− Property Tax$250
− Insurance$125
− Maintenance$208
− Vacancy Loss$57
= Net Cash Flow-$760

Investment Summary

Down Payment
$50,000
Loan Amount
$200,000
Total Monthly Expenses
$1,905
Gross Yield
5.5%

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investment decisions should be made after consulting with qualified professionals. Data sources include Zillow, Census Bureau, and BLS. Cap rates and yields are estimates based on available data.

Last updated: March 2026