Barnard College vs Middlebury College

Side-by-side comparison across admissions, costs, outcomes, campus life, and more. Data from US Department of Education.

πŸ’°
Best Value
Middlebury College
Lower Net Price
πŸ’Ό
High Earners
Barnard College
Higher 10yr Salary
πŸ†
Most Selective
Barnard College
Harder to get in
πŸŽ“
Graduation
Middlebury College
Higher success

Barnard College

New York, NY

Middlebury College

Middlebury CDP, VT
Admissions Difficulty
Acceptance Rate
8.0%
10.4%
Avg SAT Score
1,500
1,500
SAT Range (25th–75th)
1453 – 1550
1430 – 1550
Avg ACT Score
33
33
ACT Range (25th–75th)
32 – 34
33 – 34
Cost & Financial Aid
Avg Net Price
$39,253
$25,934
Tuition (In-State)
$66,246
$65,280
Tuition (Out-of-State)
$66,246
$65,280
Pell Grant Rate % students receiving Pell Grants
15.4%
16.7%
Federal Loan Rate
37.5%
22.8%
Career Outcomes
Median Salary (10yr)
$80,516
$76,310
Graduation Rate
92.2%
93.0%
Retention Rate Freshmen who return for 2nd year
96.7%
93.6%
Campus Life
Total Enrollment
3,219
2,785
Undergrad Enrollment
3,685
4,137
Type
Private
Private
Setting
Urban
Suburban

πŸ“‹ Report Cards

Barnard College

Academics
A+
Value
C
Admissions
A+
Diversity
A+

Middlebury College

Academics
A+
Value
C
Admissions
A+
Diversity
A

βš–οΈ Expert Analysis

Barnard College and Middlebury College are both well-regarded institutions, but they differ in important ways. Here's how they compare across key dimensions.

Admissions: Barnard College is more selective with a 8.0% acceptance rate compared to Middlebury College's 10.4%. Average SAT scores are 1500 and 1500 respectively.

Cost: Middlebury College offers a lower average net price at $25,934, which is $13,319 less than Barnard College ($39,253). After financial aid, this can make a significant difference over 4 years.

Career Outcomes: Graduates from Barnard College earn a median salary of $80,516 ten years after enrollment, which is $4,206 more than Middlebury College graduates ($76,310).

Graduation: Middlebury College leads with a 93.0% graduation rate, and freshman retention rates are 96.7% vs 93.6%.

Campus Size: Barnard College is the larger campus with 3,219 total students, while Middlebury College has 2,785.

Bottom Line: Middlebury College wins on affordability while Barnard College leads in career earnings. Your choice depends on whether upfront cost or long-term ROI matters more.

Want to explore more options?