Flagstaff
Investment Analysis

Flagstaff, AZ
Investor Report

Comprehensive real estate investment analysis with cap rates, rental yields, and risk assessment.

Share:
43
Investment Score
Rent
Cap Rate (Est.)
1.6%
Gross Yield
2.6%
P/R Ratio
28.9x
YoY Growth
+1.2%
Median Home Price
$710,000
Average Rent (1BR)
$1,537/mo
Median Income
$71,402
Population
76,595

Investment Breakdown

13
Value Score
62
Growth Score
55
Safety Score
59
Afford Score

Flagstaff has a price-to-rent ratio of 28.9x, which indicates renting is more favorable than buying.

The estimated cap rate of 1.6% is below average, typical of appreciation-focused markets.

Year-over-year price growth of +1.2% indicates stable market conditions.

Rental Cash Flow Analysis

Monthly Income

Gross Rent $1,537
Annual Gross $18,444

Est. Monthly Expenses

Property Tax (~1.5%) -$888
Insurance (~0.5%) -$296
Maintenance (~1%) -$592
Est. Net Cash Flow -$238/mo

Price Forecast 2026โ€“2028

๐Ÿ”ฎ Flagstaff Price Forecast 2026โ€“2028

Based on 5-year Zillow ZHVI trend analysis ยท Statistical projection
๐Ÿ“ˆ Upward Trend
PROJECTEDNOW$645K2027$703Kโ–ฒ 9.0%2028$735Kโ–ฒ 13.9%20232024Now
$771K$550K
Current
$710K
2026
Projected
$703K
โ†‘ 9.0% by 2027
Projected
$735K
โ†‘ 13.9% by 2028
5yr CAGR:+7.9%
Confidence:Moderate
Rยฒ:0.74
โ–ผ

When evaluating the Flagstaff housing market forecast through 2028, the data paints a picture of a market that is stabilizing after a period of rapid appreciation. The median home price sits at $644,626, reflecting a significant slowdown in momentum with a YoY price change of just 0.6%. This cooling is a natural correction following an impressive 5-year price change of 48.8%. For potential buyers asking "will Flagstaff home prices drop," the answer appears to be a gentle flattening rather than a sharp decline, supported by a manageable Days on Market of 61 days. The local economy, heavily influenced by Northern Arizona University and a robust tourism sector, provides a stable employment base, but the extreme affordability challenges are the primary headwind. With a Price-to-Rent Ratio of 31.6xโ€”well above the national average of 18xโ€”the financial scales tip heavily against purchasing.

The "Flagstaff real estate Flagstaff 2027" outlook is shaped by this affordability crunch. With a median rent of $1,537/mo, the rental market becomes a critical pressure valve for residents priced out of ownership, which could sustain rental demand even as sales slow. The market temperature of 57/100 and an A- risk grade suggest a balanced environment, not a fire sale. For investors and residents, the "BUY/RENT VERDICT" is clearly to RENT. This is driven by local factors like constrained land availability due to surrounding national forests and a high cost of living that limits the pool of qualified buyers. While a recession could push prices down slightly, the area's desirability as a mountain lifestyle destination provides a strong floor for values. The forecast for 2026-2028 is one of modest single-digit growth or slight stagnation, as the market absorbs the rapid gains of the past five years.

Projected Cap Rate (2027)
1.6%
5yr CAGR
+7.9%

Job Market

Unemployment 3.8%
National avg: 3.7%
Job Growth (YoY) +3.2%

Healthcare

75
Score
Good

Risk Factors

Overvalued Market

Market Activity

Source: Redfin ยท 2026-01-31
Sale-to-List 97.3%
Months Supply 3.6
Price Drops 19%
Gone in 2 Wks 21%

Market Position

Affordability Below Avg
Safety Average

ROI Projector Estimate your total return

Adjust the sliders to model different investment scenarios for Flagstaff.

Total ROI
-132%
on $142,000 invested
Annual ROI
NaN%
compounded
Total Return
-$187,734
appreciation + cashflow
Mo. Cash Flow
-$4,018
year 1 estimate
Equity Growth Over 5 Years
Y1157kY2172kY3187kY4204kY5220k
Appreciation
$45,125
Cash Flow
-$232,860
Final Equity
$220,411

* Estimates based on 1.2% annual appreciation, 3% rent growth, 5% vacancy. Does not include closing costs, tax benefits, or capital gains tax. For illustrative purposes only.

Rental Investment Calculator Estimate your monthly cashflow

Rental Income Estimator

Pre-filled for Flagstaff

Property

Purchase Price$710,000
Monthly Rent$1,537
Down Payment20%

Financing

Interest Rate6.5%

Expenses

Property Tax1.2%
Insurance (Annual)$1,500
Maintenance Reserve1%
Vacancy Rate5%
Property Management0%
HOA (Monthly)$0
-$3,557
Monthly Cash Flow
-$42,680/ year
-30.1%
Cash-on-Cash
0.1%
Cap Rate

Monthly Breakdown

+ Rental Income$1,537
โˆ’ Mortgage (P&I)$3,590
โˆ’ Property Tax$710
โˆ’ Insurance$125
โˆ’ Maintenance$592
โˆ’ Vacancy Loss$77
= Net Cash Flow-$3,557

Investment Summary

Down Payment
$142,000
Loan Amount
$568,000
Total Monthly Expenses
$5,094
Gross Yield
2.6%

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investment decisions should be made after consulting with qualified professionals. Data sources include Zillow, Census Bureau, and BLS. Cap rates and yields are estimates based on available data.

Last updated: March 2026